Now launching: antiques dealers are listing their first pieces · Are you an antiques dealer?

Antiques dealer? Join free →
Become a dealer
EUR €
  • Dealers set their prices in euros. Amounts shown in pounds and dollars are for guidance only, based on the European Central Bank rate and updated weekly.
AnticPlace Antiques dealers & exceptional pieces
EN

The Guide · Buying advice

‘Period’ or ‘in the style’?

Two words that change everything: understanding the difference and checking it on a listing.

At a glance

A ‘period Louis XV’ piece was made during the period of the style (c. 1730–1770). A piece ‘in the Louis XV style’ borrows its forms but was made later, most often in the 19th or 20th century. For equal quality, a period piece is generally worth far more than a later reproduction.

Why so much reproduction furniture?

The 19th century reproduced the styles of earlier centuries on a vast scale, from fine workshop copies to mass production. These pieces have their own interest and value, but they are not period furniture.

Signs of a period piece

  • Hand sawing: irregular marks on hidden surfaces, uneven thicknesses.
  • Pegged joints and irregular, hand-cut dovetails.
  • Hand-forged nails with irregular heads, no machine-made screws.
  • Even oxidation of unvarnished wood (interiors, backs), consistent with age.
  • Consistent wear: on feet, handles and edges handled over the centuries.
  • A stamp on Parisian furniture made between 1743 and 1791.

What the listing should state

On AnticPlace, the dealer must state explicitly whether a piece is period or in the style (a later reproduction); this is checked by our moderators and shown on the certificate given to the buyer. A seller who remains vague on this point should put you on your guard.

The great waves of copies

The taste for historical styles never died out. Under the Restauration and the July Monarchy, Louis XV and Renaissance forms came back into favour; under the Second Empire, Empress Eugénie made Louis XVI fashionable once more. In the late 19th century, leading Parisian cabinetmakers and bronze-casters such as Alfred Beurdeley, Henry Dasson and François Linke reproduced or reinterpreted the great 18th-century models with remarkable quality. In the 20th century, furniture made "in the style" became an industrial product.

What the construction gives away

  • The saw marks: regular striations from a circular or band saw on concealed surfaces.
  • The veneer: thinner and perfectly even on later copies.
  • Panels: plywood or chipboard on 20th-century furniture.
  • The drawers: fine, numerous, identical dovetails, cut by machine.
  • The mounts: electroplated gilding or mere gold-coloured lacquer, perfunctory chasing, fixed with modern screws.

For a complete method, see how to authenticate a piece of furniture.

Proportions and details

The copyist often adapted his model to the interiors of his own day: smaller dimensions, altered heights, additional drawers. He would sometimes combine ornaments from different periods on a single piece, something an 18th-century joiner or cabinetmaker would rarely have done. Carving on a later reproduction tends to be drier, the symmetry more mechanical, the marquetry too crisp and the woods too uniform in colour, for want of natural oxidation.

The grey areas

It is not all black and white. In the provinces, joiners went on making armoires and buffets in Louis XV forms long after the reign had ended: these regional pieces are antique, but they are not 'period Louis XV' in the strict sense. Other pieces are period but altered: a commode reduced in size, a replaced top, remade legs. A reputable catalogue will say so with phrases such as 'period carcass, later marquetry' or '19th century, in the Louis XVI taste'. These nuances are decisive: ask for them to appear word for word on the certificate and the invoice, so that the description of the piece remains the same from the first exchange through to the sale.

Frequently asked questions

Does reproduction furniture have any value?
Yes, especially fine 19th-century workshop copies signed by leading makers. But its price should reflect its actual date of manufacture.
What is a ‘period, restored’ piece of furniture?
A piece made during the period, some parts of which have been repaired or replaced. The extent of the restoration should be stated: an over-restored piece loses part of its value.
Can regional furniture in the Louis XV style be antique?
Yes, and it is common. Provincial workshops kept Louis XV forms alive, notably the curves and carved flowers, well into the 19th century. A Provençal or Normandy armoire in this tradition may be more than a hundred and fifty years old without being contemporary with Louis XV. It is then described as 'in the Louis XV style', with its region and actual date specified.
Is reproduction furniture ever signed?
Yes. The great Parisian houses of the 19th century often signed their furniture and bronzes, with a stamp, an engraved signature or a plaque. Such a signature is a genuine asset, but it dates the piece to the 19th century: it must never be confused with the stamp of a master cabinetmaker of the Ancien Régime.

Sources: Guillaume Janneau, Les Styles du meuble français, PUF, 'Que sais-je?' series · Musée des Arts décoratifs, Paris — permanent collections. Regulatory information is given for guidance only: please refer to the legislation currently in force.