At a glance
To authenticate a piece of furniture, professionals first examine what cannot be seen: the carcass, the backboards and drawer bottoms, the joints and the oxidation of the wood. They then check the consistency between the form, the decoration, the mounts and any stamp. No single clue is enough: it is their agreement that provides the proof.
1. Turn the piece over
The back, the underside and the drawer bottoms are rarely faked. Look for tool marks (saw, plane, jointer plane), the thickness of the boards and their oxidation: wood left bare for two centuries takes on a deep, even tone that is hard to imitate.
2. Examine the joints
Hand-cut dovetails, wooden pegs, hand-forged nails: all are signs of age. Perfectly identical dovetails or evenly threaded screws point to machine manufacture or recent intervention.
3. Study the mounts
A period bronze is chased after casting and fire-gilt with mercury: the gilding is warm and deep, with wear in logical places. Remove one if you can: old threaded rods and nuts are irregular.
4. Look for the stamp
On Parisian furniture made between 1743 and 1791, the master's stamp is struck with an iron, often on a rear upright or beneath the marble top, sometimes alongside the JME hallmark. Be wary, however: fake stamps have been struck on anonymous pieces.
5. Assess the consistency
The style, the timbers, the mounts, the marble and any restoration should all tell the same story. A marble top from another period, mounts in a different style or veneer that looks too new should be disclosed in the description.
Reading saw and plane marks
Hidden surfaces preserve a record of the tools used. A hand-sawn board shows irregular, slightly oblique striations at varying intervals. A circular saw leaves regular curved arcs, a band saw fine, straight, perfectly parallel lines: these machines became widespread in the 19th century. On backboards and inner sides, a curved-blade plane leaves gentle undulations that can be felt by hand under raking light.
Screws, nails and pegs
- Pegs: hand-cut and often slightly polygonal, they sit just proud of the surface and have taken on the same colour as the wood.
- Nails: hand-forged, with a tapering square shank and an irregular hammered head; round-shanked wire nails are later.
- Screws: old screws have an irregular thread and an often off-centre slot; machine-made screws, with an even thread and tapered point, indicate later manufacture or intervention.
- Empty holes: unused fixing holes, or a less oxidised area around a keyhole escutcheon, betray replaced hardware or mounts.
Veneer, glue and finish
Old veneer, sawn rather than rotary-cut, is thicker and less even than modern veneer. Antique furniture is assembled with animal glue (hide or bone glue), brown and brittle; a soft white or yellow glue reveals recent work. French polishing with shellac became widespread mainly in the 19th century: many earlier pieces were repolished this way, which is not a sign of a fake but a restoration that should be disclosed. A genuine patina is more worn where hands touch and more grimy in the recesses of mouldings and carvings.
Marble tops, mounts and "married" pieces
An original marble top follows the profile of the carcass exactly; its rough underside bears irregular saw marks, whereas a replacement marble has a machine-sawn, perfectly flat underside. Beneath a removed bronze mount, the wood should be less oxidised and show the mount's exact outline. Finally, check that a piece in two parts (two-part buffet, secretaire, bookcase) is not "married": wood, oxidation, tool marks and proportions should match between top and bottom. A useful method, too, for distinguishing period pieces from later pieces in the style.
Frequently asked questions
Is a stamp enough to prove authenticity?
Should a piece of furniture be appraised before you buy it?
Do woodworm holes prove a piece is old?
What is a "married" piece of furniture?
Sources: Guillaume Janneau, Les Styles du meuble français, PUF, 'Que sais-je?' series · Musée des Arts décoratifs, Paris — permanent collections. Regulatory information is given for guidance only: please refer to the legislation currently in force.