Now launching: antiques dealers are listing their first pieces · Are you an antiques dealer?

Antiques dealer? Join free →
Become a dealer
EUR €
  • Dealers set their prices in euros. Amounts shown in pounds and dollars are for guidance only, based on the European Central Bank rate and updated weekly.
AnticPlace Antiques dealers & exceptional pieces
EN

The Guide · Hallmarks & marks

Reading French silver hallmarks

From the Ancien Régime maker's mark to the Minerva head: how to date and verify a piece of silver.

At a glance

Since 1838, French silver has been marked with the Minerva head, accompanied by the number 1 (first standard, 950 ‰) or 2 (second standard, 800 ‰). Before it, the cockerel (1798–1819), with the number 1 or 2 according to the standard, then the old man's head (1819–1838) served as guarantee marks in Paris. The maker's mark, set in a lozenge, identifies the silversmith; a square mark denotes silver plate rather than solid silver.

Before the Revolution: the four marks

Under the Ancien Régime, a piece of Parisian silver was in principle struck with four marks: the maker's mark (a crowned fleur-de-lis with the silversmith's initials and device); the charge mark, struck on the unfinished piece when the duty was levied; the warden's mark or “maison commune” mark, a crowned letter changed every year that guaranteed the standard and allows the piece to be dated; and the discharge mark, applied once the duty had been paid. Paris silver was then of 958/1000 standard.

Since 1797: the state guarantee

The law of 19 Brumaire Year VI (9 November 1797) established the modern system: two legal standards for silver, 950/1000 and 800/1000, and guarantee hallmarks struck by the state. The symbols changed from period to period, which makes it possible to date pieces.

Dating table (large guarantee marks, Paris)

PeriodStandard / guarantee markKey points
before 1791Maker's, charge, warden's (date letter), dischargeDated to the year by the warden's date letter
1798 – 1819Cockerel (two successive designs)Numeral 1 or 2 depending on the standard
1819 – 1838Old man's headFirst standard, Paris
since 1838Minerva headNumeral 1 (950/1000) or 2 (800/1000)

Small items received specific hallmarks (for instance the boar's head in Paris from 1838), and provincial assay offices used their own distinguishing marks.

The maker's mark: lozenge or square?

Since 1797, the maker's mark on gold and silver has been struck within a lozenge. A square mark denotes silver plate (Christofle, Ercuis…), and such pieces never bear a Minerva head. This is the first thing to check on any piece described as “solid silver”.

The pitfalls

  • Transposed hallmarks: a mark cut from an older piece and soldered onto a later one. Look for a solder line around the mark.
  • Hallmarks worn by decades of polishing: an illegible mark proves nothing, either way.
  • Pseudo-hallmarks imitating the French system on foreign or silver-plated pieces.

Other Marks to Know

  • Small-work marks: small objects with no room for a full-size hallmark receive reduced marks, distinct from the Minerva.
  • Recense marks: when hallmarking systems changed, recense marks were struck on pieces already in circulation, so a piece may bear marks from two periods.
  • Owl: struck on pieces of unestablished origin, notably at public auction. It certifies the standard, not the date. See also our guide to gold hallmarks.
  • Import marks: foreign pieces offered for sale in France receive specific marks.

Where to Look for Hallmarks

On flatware, hallmarks are generally found on the back of the handle; on a beaker, near the rim or under the foot; on hollowware (coffee pot, dish, tureen), near the edge or under the base. Each detachable element (lid, liner, handle or nozzle) should in principle bear its own marks: a lid marked by another silversmith or from another period has probably been married. In a canteen of cutlery, a consistent maker's mark from piece to piece suggests an original set; different silversmiths or patterns point to an assembled set, which should be stated in the description. Engravings, monograms and coats of arms also help confirm that a set has always belonged to the same family.

Examining a Piece Up Close

  1. Under a ×10 loupe, in raking light: a genuine hallmark is struck into the metal, with crisp edges or edges softened by wear, never blurred like a cast mark.
  2. Around the mark: a difference in colour or a slight ridge may indicate solder.
  3. Across the surfaces: metal thinned in one spot often betrays a coat of arms or monogram that has been erased and re-engraved.
  4. On edges and raised areas: on a silver-plated object, wear reveals the underlying copper or brass, pinkish or yellowish in tone.
  5. By weight: some candlestick bases and handles are loaded with a weighting filler, so weight alone is no reliable guide.

Discover pieces described by professionals in our selection of antique silver.

Frequently asked questions

How can you tell whether a piece is solid silver?
Look for the Minerva head (used since 1838) or an earlier guarantee hallmark, together with a lozenge-shaped maker's mark. A square maker's mark without a Minerva head indicates silver plate. If in doubt, an assay office or an expert can test the standard.
What does the number on the Minerva mark mean?
The figure 1 denotes the first standard (950/1000 pure silver), the figure 2 the second standard (800/1000). The first standard is the most common for French table silver.
Can an 18th-century piece be dated precisely?
Often, yes: the letter of the jurande (guild warden's) mark changed every year, which makes it possible to date an Ancien Régime Parisian piece to the exact year, cross-referenced with the maker's mark and the guild registers.
Why does one piece bear several identical hallmarks?
Because each detachable part of a piece (lid, liner, handle, stopper) must be marked separately. Finding the same guarantee mark and the same maker's mark on every element is a good sign of consistency; a part without them, or marked differently, may have been replaced.
Can foreign silver bear French hallmarks?
Yes. Foreign pieces offered for sale in France are subject to assay control and may receive import marks in addition to their original marks. Hallmarking systems vary widely from country to country: for a foreign piece, refer to the marks of its country of manufacture and seek a specialist's opinion.

Sources: Guillaume Janneau, Les Styles du meuble français, PUF, 'Que sais-je?' series · Musée des Arts décoratifs, Paris — permanent collections. Regulatory information is given for guidance only: please refer to the legislation currently in force.