At a glance
Since 1838, French silver has been marked with the Minerva head, accompanied by the number 1 (first standard, 950 ‰) or 2 (second standard, 800 ‰). Before it, the cockerel (1798–1819), with the number 1 or 2 according to the standard, then the old man's head (1819–1838) served as guarantee marks in Paris. The maker's mark, set in a lozenge, identifies the silversmith; a square mark denotes silver plate rather than solid silver.
Before the Revolution: the four marks
Under the Ancien Régime, a piece of Parisian silver was in principle struck with four marks: the maker's mark (a crowned fleur-de-lis with the silversmith's initials and device); the charge mark, struck on the unfinished piece when the duty was levied; the warden's mark or “maison commune” mark, a crowned letter changed every year that guaranteed the standard and allows the piece to be dated; and the discharge mark, applied once the duty had been paid. Paris silver was then of 958/1000 standard.
Since 1797: the state guarantee
The law of 19 Brumaire Year VI (9 November 1797) established the modern system: two legal standards for silver, 950/1000 and 800/1000, and guarantee hallmarks struck by the state. The symbols changed from period to period, which makes it possible to date pieces.
Dating table (large guarantee marks, Paris)
| Period | Standard / guarantee mark | Key points |
|---|---|---|
| before 1791 | Maker's, charge, warden's (date letter), discharge | Dated to the year by the warden's date letter |
| 1798 – 1819 | Cockerel (two successive designs) | Numeral 1 or 2 depending on the standard |
| 1819 – 1838 | Old man's head | First standard, Paris |
| since 1838 | Minerva head | Numeral 1 (950/1000) or 2 (800/1000) |
Small items received specific hallmarks (for instance the boar's head in Paris from 1838), and provincial assay offices used their own distinguishing marks.
The maker's mark: lozenge or square?
Since 1797, the maker's mark on gold and silver has been struck within a lozenge. A square mark denotes silver plate (Christofle, Ercuis…), and such pieces never bear a Minerva head. This is the first thing to check on any piece described as “solid silver”.
The pitfalls
- Transposed hallmarks: a mark cut from an older piece and soldered onto a later one. Look for a solder line around the mark.
- Hallmarks worn by decades of polishing: an illegible mark proves nothing, either way.
- Pseudo-hallmarks imitating the French system on foreign or silver-plated pieces.
Other Marks to Know
- Small-work marks: small objects with no room for a full-size hallmark receive reduced marks, distinct from the Minerva.
- Recense marks: when hallmarking systems changed, recense marks were struck on pieces already in circulation, so a piece may bear marks from two periods.
- Owl: struck on pieces of unestablished origin, notably at public auction. It certifies the standard, not the date. See also our guide to gold hallmarks.
- Import marks: foreign pieces offered for sale in France receive specific marks.
Where to Look for Hallmarks
On flatware, hallmarks are generally found on the back of the handle; on a beaker, near the rim or under the foot; on hollowware (coffee pot, dish, tureen), near the edge or under the base. Each detachable element (lid, liner, handle or nozzle) should in principle bear its own marks: a lid marked by another silversmith or from another period has probably been married. In a canteen of cutlery, a consistent maker's mark from piece to piece suggests an original set; different silversmiths or patterns point to an assembled set, which should be stated in the description. Engravings, monograms and coats of arms also help confirm that a set has always belonged to the same family.
Examining a Piece Up Close
- Under a ×10 loupe, in raking light: a genuine hallmark is struck into the metal, with crisp edges or edges softened by wear, never blurred like a cast mark.
- Around the mark: a difference in colour or a slight ridge may indicate solder.
- Across the surfaces: metal thinned in one spot often betrays a coat of arms or monogram that has been erased and re-engraved.
- On edges and raised areas: on a silver-plated object, wear reveals the underlying copper or brass, pinkish or yellowish in tone.
- By weight: some candlestick bases and handles are loaded with a weighting filler, so weight alone is no reliable guide.
Discover pieces described by professionals in our selection of antique silver.
Frequently asked questions
How can you tell whether a piece is solid silver?
What does the number on the Minerva mark mean?
Can an 18th-century piece be dated precisely?
Why does one piece bear several identical hallmarks?
Can foreign silver bear French hallmarks?
Sources: Guillaume Janneau, Les Styles du meuble français, PUF, 'Que sais-je?' series · Musée des Arts décoratifs, Paris — permanent collections. Regulatory information is given for guidance only: please refer to the legislation currently in force.